Christine Rhyner

Christine's blogs

Brave New Frozen World (Part 3 of 4)
Thursday, November 14, 2024 by Christine

THE HUMAN GENOME PROJECT

What to do with our nation’s stockpile of frozen embryos is of concern even to those who have pioneered the actual technology. And it is inextricably intertwined with such hotly debated issues as abortion, surrogacy, “egg brokering,” cloning, and the Human Genome project (coding of the entire human genetic map). The more we are able to do on the embryonic level, which we are realizing through the Human Genome project, the more complicated it may become for couples seeking ART.

PRE-EXISTING CONDITIONS ON THE EMBRYONIC LEVEL

One technology is called “preimplantation genetics.” This technology that began with the genetic screening of an embryo for cystic fibrosis allows prospective parents to sort and choose embryos for genetic defect, discarding the ones that will potentially be born with disease. If these capabilities, as well as proposed legislation happen within reproductive medicine, it might very well be a reality for all those visiting fertility clinics to be required to have their embryos frozen, analyzed and tested for defects. From there we are potentially only a step away from genetic screening becoming required by all major health insurance companies or we run the risk of bearing offspring who cannot obtain health coverage due to their “pre-existing conditions” prior to their births. 

KILLING PEOPLE BASED ON HEALTH

Roberge explains, “Some genetic traits are actually protectors for other types of diseases.” He also points out that we can’t know in many instances to what extent a person may be affected with a genetic disorder, as in the case of Down’s Syndrome, for example. Do we have the right to decide that life may not be worth living for someone because they may face a disorder? Says Jay Johansen of the Ohio Right to Life Group, “The ‘standard practice’ in IVF is to fertilize several ova, see which ones appear to be thriving the best, pick some to implant, perhaps freeze a couple of the ‘runner ups’ and discard the rest. We find such a practice totally unacceptable, as it blatantly calls for killing people based on health.” Johansen finds the notion of parents freezing embryos comparable to that of couples having “surplus children,” then allowing only the healthiest to live. 

WHAT ARE THE LIMITS?

The issues are so interrelated and complicated, digression toward a number of hazy realms is possible. If we are willing to take the initial step of warehousing human life in freezers and accept this as “procedure” in achieving parenthood, we begin a journey with no apparent limitations.

RAMIFICATIONS

When Christians are preparing to embark upon such a course as that of ART and all of its ramifications, they should be first and foremost able to identify themselves as that of patient or consumer. There is an increasing muddying of the distinction between the two. Fertility has not as of this time been labeled a disease, and motivations do matter. Anyone with a mouse can click onto a number of websites offering the genetic material of high-quality potential sperm or egg donors. A Christian couple should have received some diagnosis, or at best, be experiencing unexplained fertility. They should ask themselves, how long have we tried to get pregnant? What is God directing us to do? Is adoption the way we are being led? Of course, there is counting the cost of ART, both in the attempt to bear offspring as well as the price of raising the multiple children that often result from it. Then there are the health risks facing both mother and child. There are inconclusive studies on the effects of such technology on either group. In addition to all of this, there should be a certain relinquishing of control over reproduction. It is often when we surrender our wills to become pregnant that we become blessed with the reality of expecting a child.

CROSSING THE LINE

Peggy Artero, for example, is a 32-year old who has not been able to conceive again since the birth of her son six years ago. Having seen a fertility specialist for the past year, she has undergone surgery to unblock both of her fallopian tubes and had artificial insemination performed some three times. “Even though my desire to have a child is overwhelming, bordering on anguish sometimes, I believe there’s a line you don’t cross trying.” She explains that crossing that line involves forfeiting her sense of peace and justice. “Even if my husband and I could afford the cost of IVF, and we were told ‘this is your only chance of becoming pregnant,’ I wouldn’t have any back up embryos made for other attempts because once it’s an embryo, it’s like giving permission to freeze my baby. Modern technology can be taken to the point where it becomes inhumane. I felt a peace about having my surgery, but not about this.” 

WORLDLY WISDOM

The Bible tells us that ours is a God of peace, not of disorder. If we examine the staggering amount of heartbreak and chaos created as society uses its knowledge to fulfill personal choice, we see much discord among the joy. If we consider that in several recent court cases women have fought to gain custody of their frozen embryos in the hopes of becoming mothers while their former spouses have fought not to become fathers, we see a distinct lack of unity. If we understand that in the majority of these cases, it is determined by our highest courts that “ordinarily, the party wishing to avoid procreation should prevail,” and that nobody is granted custody of embryos ordered destroyed, it might penetrate our hearts that “the wisdom of the world is coming to nothing.”

LEGALITIES

Of this glut of cases in which technology is outpacing law, Nigel Cameron, Senior Vice President of The Center for Bioethics and Human Dignity says, “The courts wouldn’t allow for a man to force a woman to have an abortion if he didn’t want to become a parent.” He thinks that making a decision for the destruction of embryos is like allowing a man to choose against being a parent “after the fact.” But because of the fear of questioning the life of the unborn at a period of development well before that of the twenty-two week fetus some states currently allow aborted, permission is being granted by our legal system. The sanctity of the human rights of the party wishing to avoid parenthood, even if after the fact, is allowing such fathers of frozen embryos to walk away from the consequences of their actions in pursuing IVF. By releasing them from responsibility for that which was freely consented to, participated in and created, are we not creating a whole new class of the deadbeat dad? How can it be that the same legal system that has been known to pursue this individual with a vengeance for the life he abandons after birth is the same that protects him from reaping what he has sown in a tank at the nearby fertility clinic?

CHANGED MINDS

Motive, emotion and desire affecting the lives of frozen embryos are brought to the courts by women as well as men. In the precedent-setting case of Davis v. Davis in the Supreme Court of Tennessee, Ms. Davis, who had previously fought on the state level and won the right to save the lives of the “human beings” she and her husband had made together, referred to them in Supreme Court as “potential life.” By the time the case made it to this level, Ms. Davis had remarried and held the hope of reproducing with her new husband. She no longer wished to be implanted with hers and her ex-husband’s stored and frozen embryos, but rather wished them to be donated to another couple. 

Share This Blog:


Previous Posts

"The Adopted Son Who Almost Wasn't" Excerpt Chapter 2, "Indignity"
Christine

12/9/2024

Brave New Frozen World (Part 4 of 4)
Christine

11/18/2024

Brave New Frozen World (Part 3 of 4)
Christine

11/14/2024

Brave New Frozen World (Part 2 of 4)
Christine

11/7/2024

"Hostility at the Crisis Hotline."
Christine

11/5/2024

Brave New Frozen World (Part 1 of 4)
Christine

11/1/2024

Christian Writers Conference Next Month!
Christine

7/13/2024

How Climate Change Extremism Sells Abortion (Part 2 of 2)
Christine

7/9/2024

How Climate Change Extremism Sells Abortion (Part 1 of 2)
Christine

6/25/2024

Whatever Their World View, No, The Kids Are Not Alright, Part 4 of 4
Christine

5/21/2024

Whatever Their World View, No, The Kids Are Not Alright, Part 3 of 4
Christine

5/8/2024

Whatever Their World View, No, The Kids Are Not Alright, Part 2 of 4
Christine

4/28/2024

Whatever Their World View, No, The Kids Are Not Alright, Part 1 of 4
Christine

4/18/2024

Day of Mourning, Day of Shame
Christine

1/22/2022

God's Presence With Wings
Christine

6/18/2021

The Church Needs to Unify in the Battle For Right to Life
Christine

6/10/2021

Our Sixty-Year Decline
Christine

6/1/2021

H.R. 1 Would Be A Bigger Test For The Church Than Covid Shutdowns {Part 2 of 2}
Christine

5/20/2021

H.R. 1 Would Be A Bigger Test For The Church Than Covid Shutdowns {Part 1 of 2}
Christine

5/12/2021

Dangers of Love Growing Cold
Christine

5/3/2021

Democrats' Despicable, Advantageous Use of the Elderly
Christine

4/23/2021

America, Land of Condemnation (Part Three)
Christine

4/15/2021

America, Land of Condemnation (Part Two)
Christine

4/6/2021

America, Land of Condemnation (Part One)
Christine

3/24/2021

Government's Desperate Need for Humility
Christine

3/11/2021

Is the Church Changing?
Christine

1/19/2020

What Are Our Values Anymore?
Christine

11/22/2019

The Final Frontier (Part Two)
Christine

9/4/2019

The Final Frontier (Part One)
Christine

7/29/2019

Soulmate
Christine

4/30/2019

The Colors of a Writer
Christine

12/29/2018

What's Not to Get About the Writing Life?
Christine

4/18/2018

Learning to Sing the Song of Winter
Christine

12/10/2017

Perspectives & the Second Half of the 10 Commandments of Conflict
Christine

8/25/2017

Perspectives & 5 of the 10 Commandments of Conflict
Christine

5/2/2017

Run Writer Run! Make Music with Your Words
Christine

2/15/2017

Mom, the Fishstetrician
Christine

10/14/2016

The CONSTITUTION For President
Christine

6/5/2016

The Radicalization of Hillary and the Democrat Party (PART 2 OF 2)
Christine

4/16/2016

The Radicalization of Hillary and the Democrat Party (PART 1 OF 2)
Christine

4/15/2016

Why Ted Cruz NOW?
Christine

3/19/2016

Why is the GOP Committing Suicide?
Christine

3/14/2016

Dear Chicago
Christine

3/12/2016

Does God Give Us More Than We Can Handle?
Christine

2/29/2016

That Unanswered GOP Debate Question
Christine

1/9/2016

America's Lifeline
Christine

12/31/2015

Fractured Nation (2 of 2)
Christine

11/14/2015

Fractured Nation (1 of 2)
Christine

11/11/2015

What is Orphan Sunday?
Christine

11/8/2015

November's Gratitude and Longing
Christine

11/4/2015

Losing a Child is Like...
Christine

9/12/2015

Finding God in a Tenement
Christine

9/3/2015

Doing School in the 21st Century
Christine

8/22/2015

Superstition vs. Planned Parenthood
Christine

8/19/2015

Addicted to Giving Birth?
Christine

4/21/2015

Why We Should Have "The Talk" Before Marriage
Christine

3/20/2015

Adoptive Parents "Hypersensitive" & "Selfish?"
Christine

3/12/2015

What's So Wrong With Calling It "Gotcha Day!"
Christine

2/26/2015

How God Connected the Dots
Christine

2/7/2015

Exposure of Transracially Adopted Kids to Their Races a Bad Thing?
Christine

2/2/2015

Out With The Old
Christine

1/12/2015

Those Who Scoff at International Adoption
Christine

8/16/2014

Setting Aside Birth Story Facts for Truth
Christine

7/31/2014

Sneak Peak, "How much did you pay for her?"
Christine

6/11/2014

Blessing Through Adoption Pain
Christine

5/16/2014

Eight Ways Publishing Your Book is Like an Adoption Journey
Christine

2/23/2014

Neglected Ministries?
Christine

2/17/2014

It's a Boy
Christine

2/8/2014

Thoughts of Her
Christine

2/1/2014

To My Son
Christine

1/30/2014

Rational Thinking?
Christine

1/25/2014

Minority Against Minority
Christine

1/12/2014

Happy New Year!
Christine

12/30/2013

Happy Thanksgiving
Christine

11/25/2013

You ARE my mother?
Christine

11/10/2013

The Transracially Adopted Children's Bill of Rights and Some Thoughts
Christine

11/3/2013

Infertility Is...
Christine

10/19/2013

Will He Speak English?
Christine

10/11/2013

Kitty-Sam
Christine

10/5/2013

What's in a Name?
Vhristine

9/30/2013

An Adoptive Mom's Message to Those in the Healthcare and Education Professions
Christine

9/25/2013

Being Tested
Christine

9/11/2013

When We Are Weary
Christine

9/1/2013

Trailblazers
Chrisrine

8/24/2013

A Fresh Start
Christine

8/22/2013

God Works Behind the Scenes
Christine

8/13/2013

Why Adoption Requires Forgiveness
Christine

7/28/2013

Dust Bunnies and Poo
Christine

7/19/2013

Reality Check
Christine

7/13/2013

Forgiveness is Work
Christine

7/9/2013

An Answer to Prayer, Part Three
Christine

7/3/2013

An Answer to Prayer, Part Two
Christine

6/27/2013

An Answer to Prayer, Part One
Christine

6/22/2013

Are They Really Brother and Sister?
Christine

6/16/2013

Infertility's Not Fair
Christine

6/13/2013

Has He Ever Eaten a Dog?
Christine

6/11/2013

Sometimes We Fail
Christine

6/9/2013